Open Records

Open Records > Pending Court Appeals of OOR Final Determinations

PENDING COURT APPEALS OF OOR FINAL DETERMINATIONS

If a Final Determination issued by the OOR is appealed to the courts – the Final Determination and/or court documents will appear in the “Pending Court Appeals of OOR Final Determinations” section under the Court it has been appealed to: Commonwealth Court or Court of Common Pleas. These will remain in this section until a court makes a decision on an appeal.

If a court has issued a decision on the appeal of a Final Determination – it will appear in the “Court Decisions on RTKL” section under it was appealed to: Commonwealth Court or Court of Common Pleas. NOTE: Once a court decides a pending appeal of an OOR Final Determination, It will no longer appear in the “Pending Court Appeals of OOR Final Determinations” section. "

You can SEARCH this page by pressing the “Control” and “F” keyboard keys and entering a keyword or phrase. Please be advised, the results will only return if they are contained within the page you are searching.

Commonwealth Court

	Name	Description
	20101176_Benjamin-Colonial_Intermediate_IU20.pdf	February 22, 2011
	20101037_Murphy-PTC.pdf (3)	Issued 12/01/2010 - E-ZPass usage by Turnpike employees, 74 Pa.C.S. §
	20100845_Purcell-OA.pdf (3)	Issued 10/29/2010 - Dates of birth, Constitutional right to privacy, section (b)(1), personal security, identity theft
	20100884_Wisniewski-DOC.pdf (3)	Issued 10/26/2010 - Commissary records, dismissed as moot, denied in error, records provided during appeal
	20100774_Rudberg-L&I.pdf (2)	Issued 09/20/2010 - Employment/applicant records, 708(b)(7), personal identification information, 708(b)(6), predecisional deliberations, 708(b)(10)
	20100733_Bari-Office_of_the_Governor.pdf (3)	Issued 09/13/2010 - Disruptiveness of request, 506(a), Bari decision, ‘records,’ confidential proprietary information, 708(b)(11)
	20100722_Zloczwer-PSP.pdf (2)	Issued 09/03/2010 - Police records, sufficiently specific, medical records, CHRIA
	20100686_Loomis-IUP.pdf (3)	Issued 08/25/2010 - Financial records, donor records, identities, 708(b)(13)
	20100661_Folletti-Edinboro_University.pdf (3)	Issued 08/18/2010 - Construction project documents, physical possession, 506(d), governmental function, directly related
	20100603_Giurintano-DGS.pdf (3)	Issued 08/02/2010 - Third party records, 506(d)(1), identity information, 708(b)(11), 708(b)(6), confidential proprietary information
	20100542_Campbell-Office_of_the_Budget.pdf (3)	Issued 07/29/2010 - W-2s, home address, retirement, names, redaction
	20100586_Tuthill-PSP.pdf (3)	Issued 07/27/2010 - Training materials, burden not met, insufficient affidavit.
	20100585_Smolsky-DOC_FD.pdf (3)	Issued 07/26/2010 - P.A.C.T. Classification Form, 708(b)(1)
	20100550_Prine-PSP.pdf (3)	07/15/2010 - Supplemental employment forms & responses, 708(b)(17) or (b)(10) or (b)(1), redaction
	20100481_Scolforo-PSP_FD.pdf (2)	Issued 07/14/2010 - Supplemental Employment forms and responses and records related to outside work, redaction, 708(b)(17), 708(b)(10) and 708(b)(6)
	20100468_Piccone-Dept_of_State.pdf	Issued 06/23/2010 - Medical license records, noncriminal investigative (b)(17)
	20100261_Rizzuto-DOC.pdf	Issued 04/26/2010 - Medical records, employee names and information
	20100246_Ford-Edinboro_Univ.pdf (2)	Issued 04/21/2010 - Certified payrolls, possession of contractor
	20100125_Kaplin-Lower_Merion_Twp.pdf	Issued 03/26/2010 - Conditional Use Application, attorney/client privilege, waiver, predecisional deliberative
	20100144_Atwood-IUP.pdf	Issued 03/19/2010 - Certified payrolls, SF-1413's, insufficient affidavit
	2009-0718_McShane-HACC.pdf	Issued 09/30/2009 - Training materials, curriculum from law enforcement DUI training class
	2009-0438_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf (4)	Issued 07/08/2009 - Twp Supervisor emails, Twp control, records prior to 2009
	2009-0310_Czech-York_County.pdf	Issued 05/22/2009 - 911 time response log, incident addresses
	2009-0281_Schneller-Gaming_Control_Board.pdf	Issued 05/11/2009 - Agency cannot refuse to respond to request for failure to comply with its policies
	2009-0141_Zubey-DEP.pdf	Issued 04/03/2009 - Copying and certifying records upon request; attorney-client privilege
	2009-0058_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 03/11/2009 - Emails (among Twp Supervisors - including personal email addresses)
	2009-0042_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 03/05/2009 - Emails (among Twp Supervisors - including personal email addresses)
	2011-0343 Dent- Clinton County Clerk of Court.pdf
	Allegheny_Cty_Admin_Srvces-Parsons_&_OOR_(OOR_Docket_20090670).pdf	Allegheny Cty CCP, No. SA 09-1124
	Barkeyville_Borough-Wallace_&_Stearns_(OOR_Docket_20100404).pdf	Venango Cty CCP, No. CV NO 906-2010
	2009-0892_Froelich-DPW.pdf	Issued 10/28/2010 - REMAND: Fee waiver, non-discriminatory reason

Court of Common Pleas

	Name	Description
	20101222_Taverna-Palmer_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 01/21/2011 - Development records, privilege, questions
	20101209_James-York_Cty.pdf (3)	Issued 01/21/2011 - Records do not exist. Due process.
	20101216_McGill-Bangor_Borough.pdf (3)	Issued 01/21/2011 - Grievance material, 708(b)(7)(vii), 708(a)(1), Lutz
	20101076_Cass-Butler_Cty_Industrial_Development_Auth.pdf (3)	Issued 01/03/2011 - Nonresponsive agency
	20101113_Campbell-Fox_Chapel_Area_SD.pdf (2)	Issued 12/17/2010 - Property tax assessment records, public school employee addresses redacted, public school employees’ addresses on Statements of Financial Interest, Injunction
	20101098_Boren-Montour_SD.pdf (2)	Issued 12/07/2010 - Investigation into mismanagement of funds, 708(b)(17)
	20101068_Senseman-Marple_Newtown_SD.pdf (3)	Issued 11/30/2010 - Certified payrolls (redacted), agency control
	20100961_Lazur-Rush_Twp.pdf (2)	Issued 11/05/2010 - Financial records, redaction, account number
	20100955_Laigle-City_of_Pittsburgh.pdf (3)	Issued 11/05/2010 - - Use of force policies, disruptive requester, agency burden
	20100863_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 11/05/2010 - Emails relating to appeals, personal computer, control, privileged
	20100869_Tignall-Dallastown_Area_SD.pdf (3)	Issued 10/22/2010 - Municipal election records, records do no exist, records not "of" the agency
	20100797_Fike-Unity_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 09/22/2010 - Building plans, personal security, 708(b)(1), physical security, 708(b)(3), late submission by agency
	20100738_Van_Osdol-City_of_Pittsburgh_Housing_Auth.pdf (3)	Issued 09/22/2010 - Names of landlord, property address, Section 8 housing, Social services.
	20100764_Chotiner-Philadelphia_PD.pdf (3)	Issued 09/13/2010 - Financial records
	20100742_McKenna-Lower_Providence_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 08/31/2010 - Emails, communications, late response by agency, burden not met
	20100701_Cap-Lehigh_Cty.pdf (3)	Issued 08/26/2010 - Video, Magistrate court, record does not exist
	20100703_George-Mt_Lebanon_PD.pdf (3)	Issued 08/25/2010 - Police policies, traffic enforcement, search and seizure, public safety exemption
	20100677_Hollowood-Latrobe_Municiap_Auth.pdf (3)	Issued 08/25/2010 - Development plan records, agency did not assert exception, account statements, no records exist
	20100667_Colwyn_Borough-Delaware_Cty.pdf (3)	Issued 08/20/2010 - Park Police work hours/days, schedules and rotation/consistency, no affidavits (b)(2)
	20100651_Kollock-Falls_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 08/18/2010 - Education, training, promotion, employee information, 708(b)(6), (7), Internal Affairs investigation records, noncriminal investigation
	20100623_Pilchesky-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf (3)	Issued 08/06/2010 - Sheriff's Office property records, records do not exist
	20100338_Fikry-Allegheny_Cty_Dept_of_Admin_Services.pdf (3)	Issued 07/30/2010 - Administrative Services documents, records of another agency
	20100552_Dunbar_LPVRSA-Lower_Providence_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 07/19/2010 - Supervisor email accounts, attorney/client privilege, noncriminal investigation, predecisional deliberations
	20100505_Trego-Slatington_Borough.pdf	Issued 07/07/2010 - Employee discharge documents, agency did not meet burden
	20100457_Keating-Covington_Twp.pdf	Issued 06/23/2010 - Plumbing inspection compliance reports
	20100456_Keating-Covington_Twp.pdf	Issued 06/23/2010 - Mechanical inspection compliance reports
	2009-0989_White-Phoenixville_Area_SD.pdf	Issued 06/09/2010 - Documents regarding Davis property, agency did not meet burden
	20100420_Lynch-Locust_Twp.pdf	Issued 06/07/2010 - Police matter policy statements, agency did not meet burden
	20100344_Thomas-Lebanon_Cty.pdf	Issued 05/18/2010 - Visitor and mail log records, provided during appeal, dismissed as moot
	20100313_DeLuca-Conemaugh_Twp_Auth.pdf	Issued 05/12/2010 - Delinquint sewer account information
	20100301_Stover-Conemaugh_Twp.pdf	Issued 05/10/2010 - W-2's, 708(b)(6)
	20100228_Wallack-Narberth_Boro.pdf	Issued 04/14/2010 - Property leases and improvements, non-responsive agency
	20100206_Schillinger-Lackawanna_Cty_Multi-purpose_Stadium_Auth.pdf	Issued 04/14/2010 - Naming rights contract, 506(d), governmental function
	20100157_Bari-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf	Issued 04/07/2010 - Minutes of a non profit organization on which the mayor sits in his official capacity as the mayor, record of the agency
	20100171_Renshaw-City_of_Allentown.pdf	Issued 03/29/2010 - City contract documents, internal, predecisional deliberations
	20100154_Miller-Belle_Vernon_Fire_Dept.pdf (2)	Issued 03/22/2010 - Fire report, redaction of personal info, Fire dept is local agency, non-responsive
	20100109_Witmer-Shamokin_Area_SD.pdf	Issued 03/08/2010 - Correspondence, Agency did not meet burden, no affadavit provided
	20100065_Maley-Greene_Cty.pdf	Issued 02/22/2010 - Policies regarding inmate release, agency did not provide response
	2009-1152_Warner-Annville_Twp.pdf	Issued 02/19/2010 - Home addresses of landlords within Township
	2009-1100_Lenning-Monroe_Cty.pdf	Issued 02/05/2010 - e-mail and text messages, specificity, personnel/disciplinary records, Child Protective Services Law
	2009-1099_Bittenbender-Monroe_Cty.pdf	Issued 02/05/2010 - E-mail and text messages, specificity, personnel/disciplinary records, Child Protective Services Law
	20100015_Marshall-Neshaminy_SD.pdf	Issued 02/05/2010 - Leases, appraisals, reports, 708(b)(22), 708(b)(10), internal and deliberative
	2009-1126_Evans-York_Cty.pdf	Issued 01/21/2010 - Prison visitor's logs
	2009-0980_Andrekovich-Bellwood_Antis_SD.pdf	Issued 01/19/2010 - Grant application documents
	2009-0926_Acton-Fort_Cherry_SD.pdf	Issued 12/31/2009 - Request for electronic documents, ability to redact electronic documents
	2009-0916_Najarian-North_Whitehall_Twp.pdf	Issued 12/30/2009 - Map in possession of Township as part of zoning hearing, copyright law
	2009-1013_Renshaw-City_of_Allentown.pdf	Issued 12/23/2009 - Partial denial with redaction requires reason for redaction
	2009-1007_Portnoy-Bucks_Cty.pdf	Issued 12/21/2009 - Building entry information, 708(b)(2) and (b)(3)
	2009-0925_Kupetz Jenkins_Twp.pdf	Issued 12/18/2009 - Permit permit, no ground for not producing 30-year old records, agency did not establish it reviewed records
	2009-0945_Addelspurger-Allegheny_Cty.pdf	Issued 12/03/2009 - JNET records, Agency did not respond, did not meet burden
	2009-0861_Hurewitz-CSIU.pdf	Issued 11/18/2009 - Closed hearing decisions, student information, redaction
	2009-0722_Wentworth-Chester_Cty.pdf	Issued 10/27/2009 - Emails, federal law suit outside of RTKL, discovery
	2009-0796_Churchill-Lebanon_SD.pdf	Issued 10/26/2009 - Citations and other truancy related records, FERPA, redaction required
	2009-0634_Mahl-Springfield_Twp.pdf	Issued 10/16/2009 - Complaints, noncriminal investigations
	2009-0790_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf	Issued 10/13/2009 - Email correspondence of twp supervisor on personal computers, repetitive request, clarification of past request
	2009-0787_Shields-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf (2)	Issued 10/13/2009 - Past daily schedules of Mayor and Council members, 708(b)(10), predecisional deliberations, work papers 708(b)(12), 708(b)1)(ii) personal security, public safety 708(b)(2)
	2009-0731_Mollick-Worcester_Two.pdf	Issued 10/08/2009 - Emails between supervisors and solicitor, on personal computer, attorney-client privilege
	2009-0691_Wentworth-Chester_Cty.pdf	Issued 10/05/2009 - Records do not exist, no affidavit provided by agency
	2009-0775_Lord-City_of_Pittsburgh.pdf	Issued 10/02/2009 - Dates of birth, 708(b)1(iii), Constitution
	2009-0760_Tomlinson-Clearfield_Cty.pdf	Issued 09/28/2009 - Third party contractor certified payrolls
	2009-0759_Rehbein-Northern_Lehigh_SD.pdf	Issued 09/25/2009 - Retired school employee addresses, Commonwealth Court injunction
	2009-0752_Rehbein-Penn_Argyl_SD.pdf	Issued 09/24/2009 - Retired school employee addresses, Commonwealth Court injunction
	2009-0643_Signature_Info_Solutions-Upper_Dublin_Twp.pdf	Issued 08/24/2009 - Tax records, necessarily incurred cost
	2009-0607_Agre-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf	Issued 08/17/2009 - Home addresses, third party contractors, Constitutional right to privacy
	2009-0611_Rogan-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf	Issued 08/12/2009 - Third party records re: governmental function, 506(d)(1), redaction supported by exception/evidence
	2009-0589_Smydo-Pittsburgh_SD.pdf	Issued 08/10/2009 - Purchase quotes, internal deliberations, 708(b)10
	2009-0544_Signature Info-Warminster_Twp.pdf	Issued 08/07/09 - Tax information
	2009-0521_Signature Info-Middletown_Twp.pdf	Issued 08/06/2009 - Tax info, creation of records
	2009-0528_Roman-Mount_Joy_Twp.pdf	Issued 07/24/2009 - Twp Supervisor Power Point presentation, Twp control
	2009-0486_Meachem-East_Stroudsburg_SD.pdf	Issued 07/10/2009 - Agency issued cell phone numbers
	2009-0475_Campbell-William_Penn_SD.pdf	Issued 07/08/2009 - Home addresses, PA Constitution, 708(b)6, personal security
	2009-0263_Purcell-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf	Issued 06/12/2009 - Home addresses, dates of birth, law enforcement officer definition
	2009-0401_Buffer-Luzerne_County.pdf	Issued 06/10/2009 - HIPAA – wanted amount paid for employee benefits, lack of specificty
	2009-0289_Signature_Info_Solutions-Montgomery_Twp.pdf	Issued 05/15/2009 - Tax information
	2009-0223_Ruth-Northern_York_SD.pdf	Issued 04/22/2009 - Coaching improvement plan, Section 708(b)(7)
	2009-0104_Brubaker-Lancaster_Cty.pdf	Issued 04/17/2009 - Autopsy reports, RTKL and Coroner's Act
	2009-0096_RoganJ-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf	Issued 04/15/2009 - Contract of a third-party contractor with another private company
	2009-0168_Schillinger-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf	Issued 04/13/2009 - third party, trade secrets, confidential proprietary information
	2009-0077_Donahue-Luzerne_Cty.pdf	Issued 03/13/2009 - Emails and private entity
	2011-0071 Iverson- Montgomery County.pdf	1 FINAL DETERMINATION IN THE MATTER OF : : PAUL IVERSON, : Complainant : : Docket No. AP 2011-0071 v. : : MONTGOMERY COUNTY, :
	2011-0309 McClintock- Coatesville Area SD.pdf	1 FINAL DETERMINATION IN THE MATTER OF : : ROBERT MCCLINTOCK, : Complainant : : Docket No.: AP 2011-0309 v. : : COATESVILLE AREA :
	2011-0377 Johnson- PA Convention Center Authority.pdf
	2011-0400 Campbell- Lower Moreland Township SD.pdf
	2011-0359_Express_Times-Easton Area SD.pdf
	2011-0543 Crockett- SEPTA.pdf
	2011-0597 Friends of Farmworkers Inc- City of Philadelphia.pdf
	20101172_Loughery-Salford_Twp.pdf (3)	Issued 01/06/2011 - Records sought from Supervisors , records provided during appeal
	2011-0019 Streck- Lower Macungie Twp.pdf
	2011-0399 Breneman- Kennett Consolidated SD.pdf
	2011-0594 Campbell- Butler Area SD.pdf
	2011-0044 Goolsby- SEPTA.pdf
	2011-0093 Crockett- SEPTA.pdf
	2011-0542 Crockett- SEPTA.pdf
	2011-0215 Hoyer- Lebanon County Clerk of Courts.pdf
	2011-0372 Pittsburgh Post_Gazette-Allegheny County.pdf	1 FINAL DETERMINATION IN THE MATTER OF : : THE PITTSBURGH POST-GAZETTE, : Complainant : : v. : Docket No. AP 2011-0372 : ALLEGHENY
	2011-0323_Nalls- Philadelphia Police Department.pdf
	2011-0525 Carey- Clairton City School District.pdf
	2011-0606 D'Agostino- Lower Merion Township.pdf	FINAL DETERMINATION IN THE MATTER OF : : MICHAEL D’AGOSTINO, : Complainant : : v. : Docket No. AP 2011-0606 : LOWER MERION TOWNSHIP
	2011-0078 Parker- Philadelphia DA.pdf
	2011-0568R Campbell-West Chester Area SD.pdf
	2011-0737 Gurdine-- Philadelphia Police Department.pdf

Judicially Decided

	Name	Description
	20100136_Pilchesky-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf	Issued 03/18/2010 - Invoices/billngs, attorney/client privilege
	2009-1146_Marks-Delaware_Cty.pdf	Issued 01/20/2010 - Dog owner's home addresses, with exception of public school employees
	2009-0857_Sherry-Radnor_Twp_SD.pdf	Issued 11/04/2009 - Disciplinary records/honor code violations, identifying information
	2009-0737_Signature_Info_Solutions-Chester_Water_Auth.pdf	Issued 09/21/2009 - Use of OOR uniform request form, "Certification" of record
	2009-0502_Anderson-Sharon_Sanitary_Auth.pdf	Issued 08/21/2009 - Records of delinquent accounts, Fair Credit Extension Uniformity Act
	2009-0439_Signature_Info_Solutions-Springfield_Twp.pdf	Issued 06/19/2009 - tax records, creation of record, agency records in possession of third party (tax collector), printout is not creation of record
	2009-0390_Campbell-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf	Issued 06/11/2009 - W-2 information
	2009-0342_Campbell-Susquehanna_Twp_SD.pdf	Issued 05/29/2009 - W-2's, union dues
	2009-0305_Zeldenrust-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf	Issued 05/20/2009 - W-2's, mileage reimbursement/automobile allowances
	2009-0170_Stidmon-Blackhawk_SD.pdf	Issued 05/20/2009 - Teacher grievance lawsuits, agency non-compliance with RTKL
	2009-0205_Hardy-Chester_Community_Charter_School.pdf	Issued 05/08/2009 - Thirdy party contract, 506(d)
	2009-0262_Felder-East_Stroudsburg_Area_SD.pdf	Issued 05/08/2009 - Predecisional communications
	2009-0203_Yarnall-Butler_Cty_Coroner.pdf	Issued 04/20/2009 - Coroner's reports
	2009-0110_Berrett-East_Stroudsburg_Univ.pdf	Issued 04/10/2009 - Non-profit entity created, governmental function, documents related to that service
	2009-0116_Pierce-Morris_Twp_Fire_Dept.pdf	Issued 04/03/2009 - Volunteer fire company, HIPAA statutory exemption
	2009-0161_Stein-Plymouth Twp.pdf	Issued 04/03/2009 - Complaints, noncriminal investigations
	2009-0067_Blasi-Pen_Argyl_SD.pdf	Issued 03/11/2009 - Class rosters, coach plans, parent's addresses
	2009-0039_Zurat-Norwegian_Twp.pdf	Issued 03/03/2009 - Payroll information
	2009-0434_Campbell-York_Cty.pdf	Issued 06/25/2009 - Home addresses, county employees