Open Records > Final Determinations
 
 


FINAL DETERMINATIONS OF THE OFFICE OF OPEN RECORDS


Are Final Determinations Binding? Final Determination Information

If a Final Determination issued by OOR is appealed to the Courts - it will appear in the APPEALED section under the Court it has been appealed to: Commonwealth Court or Court of Common Pleas.  If a court has issued an opinion on a Final Determination - it will appear in the APPEALED section under the heading JUDICIALLY DECIDED.  It will also appear on the page titled "JUDICIAL DECISIONS"

2009 - 1159 appeals were docketed

2010  -  108 appeals have been docketed, as of 2/4/2010

You can SEARCH the Final Determination page and the Appealed Final Determinations page by pressing the "Control" and "F"  keyboard keys and entering a keyword or phrase

 

Final Determinations February 2010  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-1009_Prine-Green_Tree_Boro.pdf Issued 02/05/2010 - Transcript and legal invoices
PDF Documents 2009-1099_Bittenbender-Monroe_Cty.pdf Issued 02/05/2010 - E-mail and text messages, specificity, personnel/disciplinary records, Child Protective Services Law
PDF Documents 2009-1100_Lenning-Monroe_Cty.pdf Issued 02/05/2010 - e-mail and text messages, specificity, personnel/disciplinary records, Child Protective Services Law
PDF Documents 20100012_Fikry-Allegheny_Cty_Retirement_Brd.pdf Issued 02/05/2010 - Attorney/client privilege, records do not exist
PDF Documents 20100013_Kaplin-Lower_Merion_Twp.pdf Issued 02/05/2010 - Emails, 708(b)(10 predecisional, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 20100005_Miller-PennDot.pdf Issued 02/04/2010 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1132_Gross-Versailles_Boro.pdf Issued 02/03/2010 - Dismissed as moot, records provided
PDF Documents 2009-1128_Gross-Versailles_Boro.pdf Issued 02/03/2010 - Maps, all responsive records provided, no other records exist
PDF Documents 20100007_Romano-Chalfont_Boro.pdf Issued 02/03/2010 - Police Commission financial analysis, 708(b)(10). internal usage
PDF Documents 2009-1149_Fikry-Retirement_Brd_of_Allegheny_Cty.pdf Issued 02/01/2010 - Retirement board records, attorney client, privilege work product records, do not exist, good faith effort
PDF Documents 20100001_Lehigh_Valley_Planning_Comm-PennDOT.pdf Issued 02/01/2010 - Engineering studies/analysis, 708(b)(10), predecisional deliberative
PDF Documents 2009-1104_McKeeson-DPW.pdf Issued 02/01/2010 - RFP records, Procurement code; predecisional deliberations
PDF Documents 20100002_Porter-Tower_Joint_Muni_Auth-Tower-City_Water_Auth.pdf Issued 02/01/2010 - Agency did not meet burden, not establish that any exception applied to protect water meter readings of customers
Final Determinations January 2010  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0977_Evans-Rose_Tree_Media_SD.pdf Issued 01/29/2010 - Property tax settlement, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0971_Campbell-Community_College_of_Phila.pdf Issued 01/29/2010 - College teacher home address, Commonwealth Court Order
PDF Documents 2009-1141_Buehl-DOC.pdf Issued 01/27/2010 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1147_Hanes-Sugar_Grove_Volunteer_FD.pdf Issued 01/27/2010 - Volunteer fire department, records, minutes
PDF Documents 2009-1142_Gardner-DOC.pdf Issued 01/27/2010 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1145_Maley-Greene_Cty.pdf Issued 01/26/2010 - Public Defender application, Agency has no possession/control
PDF Documents 2009-1138_Stein-PSP.pdf Issued 01/26/2010 - Police blotter, criminal investigation records, rap sheet, CHRIA
PDF Documents 2009-1097-Simone-Owen_J_Roberts_SD.pdf Issued 01/25/2010 - Security clearances/background checks, Act 34 and 151
PDF Documents 2009-1140_Thompson-Philadelphia_PD.pdf Issued 01/25/2010 - Investigative records, 708(b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-1126_Evans-York_Cty.pdf Issued 01/21/2010 - Prison visitor's logs
PDF Documents 2009-1133_Pilchesky-Scranton_Municipal_Rec_Auth.pdf Issued 01/21/2010 - Final contract as of date of request, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1077_Lemley-Perry_Twp.pdf Issued 01/21/2010 - Redacted attorney invoices, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-1136_Regnell-ELCO_SD.pdf Issued 01/21/2010 -Special Ed. Settlement Agreement, redaction, PII, FERPA, 708(b)(1)
PDF Documents 2009-1088_Moss-Londonderry_Twp.pdf Issued 01/20/2010 - TMI permit applications, 708(b)(3)
PDF Documents 2009-1124_Guarrasi-Bucks_Cty.pdf Issued 01/20/2010 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1076_Barts-South_Eastern_SD.pdf Issued 01/20/2010 - School bus turnarounds, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1146_Marks-Delaware_Cty.pdf Issued 01/20/2010 - Dog owner's home addresses, with exception of public school employees
PDF Documents 2009-1122_Dakessian-Lancaster_Cty.pdf Issued 01/19/2010 - Specificity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0980_Andrekovich-Bellwood_Antis_SD.pdf Issued 01/19/2010 - Grant application documents
PDF Documents 2009-1118_Leslie-Ambridge_SD.pdf Issued 01/19/2010 - Non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-0975_Pry-Office_of_the_Budget.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Certified payrolls, 506(d)
PDF Documents 2009-0982_Cap-LANTA.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Audio/video recording, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1025_Serfass-Discovery_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1028_Serfass-Global_Leadership_Academy_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1042_Serfass-World_Communications_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1064_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Legal invoices, emails on personal computers, attorney/client privilege, agency possession
PDF Documents 2009-1114_Miller-Edinboro_Univ.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Personnel records, written criticism, 708(b)(7)
PDF Documents 2009-1023_Serfass-Antonia_Pantoja_Community_Charte_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1024_Serfass-Arise_Academy_High_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1029_Serfass-Harambee_Inst_of_Science_Tech_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1032_Serfass-Maritime_Academy_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1040_Serfass-West_Oak_Lane_Charter_School.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Employee information, non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-1116_Carpenter-Game_Commission.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Hunting license info, Game & Wildlife Code, Sec 325
PDF Documents 2009-1117_Crouser-Fayette_Cty_Coroner.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - Autopsy report, Coroner's Act, fee
PDF Documents 2009-1119_Hewitt-Newtown_Twp_PD.pdf Issued 01/15/2010 - 911 call recordings, criminal investigative records, no jurisdiction
PDF Documents 2009-1111_Tighe-General_McLane_SD.pdf Issued 01/14/2010 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1098_McTeague-Quakertown_Community_SD.pdf Issued 01/13/2010 - Certified payroll, unredacted copies provided
PDF Documents 2009-1115_Pilchesky-City_of_Scranton.pdf Issued 01/13/2010 - Existing records were supplied, other records of payments do not to exist
PDF Documents 2009-1109_Mychak-Mt_Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 01/13/2010 - Permits and accompanying checks; Agency did not submit grounds for not public record
PDF Documents 2009-0905_Vorkink-Dept_of_Revenue.pdf Issued 01/12/2010 - Lottery sales data: records provided, no response from Requester if Request satisfied
PDF Documents 2009-1101_Renshaw-City_of_Allentown.pdf Issued 01/12/2010 - Redactions from e-mails to tax collection agency, Local Tax Enabling Act, confidential tax info and (b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-1106_Mychak-Mt_Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 01/12/2010 - Minutes, meeting tapes and treasurer's report from public meeting
PDF Documents 2009-1107_Mychak-Mt_Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 01/12/2010 - Contract w/ attorne, billing rate and explanation of retainer
PDF Documents 2009-1108_Mychak-Mt_Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 01/12/2010 - Ordinance
PDF Documents 2009-0986_Nychis-North_Versailles_Twp.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Solicitor's invoices, minimal redaction, affadavit regarding privilege
PDF Documents 2009-1014_Bauder-SERS.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Fee issue, per copy cost, retrieval charge
PDF Documents 2009-1074_Hensil-Adams_Cty.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Fees, property assessment data, fair market value
PDF Documents 2009-1094_Litvak-L&I.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Specificity, creation of a record
PDF Documents 2009-1091_Moore-Steel_Valley_SD.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Step decisions of teachers, no exception asserted
PDF Documents 2009-1092_Mauriello-SERS.pdf Issued 01/11/2010 - Administrative fee charges
more...
Final Determinations December  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-1069_Rolle-Butler_Twp.pdf Issued 12/31/2009 - Complaints, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0926_Acton-Fort_Cherry_SD.pdf Issued 12/31/2009 - Request for electronic documents, ability to redact electronic documents
PDF Documents 2009-1068_Rolle-Butler_Twp.pdf Issued 12/31/2009 - Final release of project funds, agency did not meet burden
PDF Documents 2009-1053_Kehoe-DOC.pdf Issued 12/30/2009 - Reports, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-1056_Kretchmar-DOC.pdf Issued 12/30/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1006_Metzli-Slippery_Rock_Boro.pdf Issued 12/28/2009 - Request consisting of answers to question, police work schedules, 708(b)(2)
PDF Documents 2009-0862_Maley-Greene_Cty.pdf Issued 12/28/2009 - Recorded inmate phone calls, Wiretap law
PDF Documents 2009-0924_Jaworski-PSP.pdf Issued 12/28/2009 - Incident report. subject to redaction of noncriminal investigation non-blotter information
PDF Documents 2009-0676_Bari-City_of_Philadelphia_&_IVCC.pdf Issued 12/24/2009 - Non-profit organization, is it an agency subject to RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0951_Ehrlich-Beaver_Cty.pdf (2) Issued 12/24/2009 - Files provided by third party not shown to not exist, and as data exists, it must be provided
PDF Documents 2009-1011_Schillinger-Lackawanna_Cty.pdf Issued 12/23/2009 - Inappropriate emails related to suspension, Agency did not meet burden
PDF Documents 2009-0998_DeLong-Maxatawny_Municipal_Auth.pdf Issued 12/22/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0991_Klach-Northwestern_Lehigh_SD.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Access sought, not copies; use of form, extension of time
PDF Documents 2009-0995_Moss-Londonderry_Twp.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Building permit with information about plans, utility and electrical systems, 708(b)(3)
PDF Documents 2009-0997_Wheelock-DOC.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Inmate request for personal documents, 708(b)(5), (b)(26) and (b)(6), other items not public records
PDF Documents 2009-0999_Nietupski-East_Rockhill_Twp.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Questions are not a proper Right-to-Know request, creation of a record
PDF Documents 2009-0994_Jelsma-McNett_Twp.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Correspondence, record does not exist, affadavit sufficient evidence
PDF Documents 2009-0996_Miller-DOC.pdf Issued 12/21/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0993_Brusen-PennDOT.pdf Issued 12/18/2009 - Proposed budget and plans, pre-decisional, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-1062_Konias-Dravosburg_Borough.pdf Issued 12/18/2009 - Former employee's personnel records, 708(b)(7), record of discharge or demotion action by agency
PDF Documents 2009-0901_Hocker-Young_Scholars_Charter_School.pdf Issued 12/17/2009 - Employee applications and resumes, specificty, appeal of request with sub-parts
PDF Documents 2009-0954_Sarr-Bucks_Cty.pdf Issued 12/17/2009 - Oaths of office, contract, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0978_Jackson-DOH.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Specificity of request, medical/treatment records, non-criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0983_Cap-LANTA.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Audio/video record, entire record provided - audio not available
PDF Documents 2009-0987_Kinsella-PennDOT.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Prepayment of fees, redaction, inspection
PDF Documents 2009-0863_Maley-Greene_Cty_Public_Defender.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Public Defender services application, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0892_Froelich-DPW.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Fee waiver
PDF Documents 2009-0979_Young-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Legal Custody records, 37 Pa. Code §61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0864_Maley-Greene_Cty.pdf Issued 12/16/2009 - Prison visitation room recordings, personal security 708(b)(1)
PDF Documents 2009-0969_Little-PSP.pdf Issued 12/14/2009 - PICS records, non criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0985_Hoyer-Lebanon_Cty.pdf Issued 12/14/2009 - Disciplinary records, final agency action on demotion/discharge, 708(b)(7)
PDF Documents 2009-0972_Urbina-Office_of_the_Governor.pdf Issued 12/14/2009 - Specificity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0973_Andrews-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 12/14/2009 - Investigative report and documents, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0904_Malinsky-Robinson_Twp.pdf Issued 12/14/2009 - Non-audit workpapers, general ledger adjusting entries,
PDF Documents 2009-0910_Bowser-Carroll_Twp.pdf Issued 12/09/2009 - Event expenses, individual records
PDF Documents 2009-0962_Polite-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/08/2009 - Legal custody records, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0963_Pendrak-North_Pocono_SD.pdf Issued 12/08/2009 - Agency does not possess records, referral to proper agency
PDF Documents 2009-0957_Sanders-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/07/2009 - Agency investigation results, 708(b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-0960_Sarr-SOAB.pdf Issued 12/07/2009 - Board assessment records, criminal investigative 708(b)(16)
PDF Documents 2009-0958_Sarr-SOAB.pdf Issued 12/07/2009 - Board assessment records, criminal investigative 708(b)(16)
PDF Documents 2009-0959_Sarr-SOAB.pdf Issued 12/07/2009 - Board assessment records, criminal investigative 708(b)(16)
PDF Documents 2009-0935_Beisuz-Export_Fire_Dept.pdf Issued 12/04/2009 - Volunteer fire department, subject to RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0891_Bari-Delaware_River_Waterfront_Corp.pdf Issued 12/04/2009 - Agency status, private nonprofit development corp
PDF Documents 2009-0903_Campbell-L&I.pdf Issued 12/04/2009 - Non-appeal related redaction not identified
PDF Documents 2009-0948_Fantone-DOC.pdf Issued 12/03/2009 - Medical records, 708(b)(5)
PDF Documents 2009-0947_Poulson-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/03/2009 - Legal custody records, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0952_Robinson-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/03/2009 - Legal custody records, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0953_Williams-PBPP.pdf Issued 12/03/2009 - Legal custody records, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0939_Heberling-Clearfield_Jefferson_MH-MR.pdf Issued 12/02/2009 - Mental health records, power of attorney, 708(b)(5)
PDF Documents 2009-0940_Wehrmann-PSP.pdf Issued 12/02/2009 - Criminal history records, CHRIA
more...
Final Determinations November  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0920_Morrissette-DOC.pdf Issued 11/30/2009 - Records related to inmate: medical, psychological, education - 708(b)(1), (b)(2), (b)(17), (b)(15), (b)(5)
PDF Documents 2009-0933_Gibson-PBPP.pdf Issued 11/30/2009 - Parole records, legal custody, 37 Pa. Code §61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0921_Doherty-Radnor_Twp_FD.pdf Issued 11/30/2009 - Property complaints and enforcement actions, noncriminal complaints 708(b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-0929_Anderson-Hampton_Twp.pdf Issued 11/30/2009 - Agency possession/control over third-party contractor records, governmental function
PDF Documents 2009-0931_Bartley-Lock_Haven_Univ.pdf Issued 11/30/2009 - Emails, redaction based on FERPA and 708(b)(1),(6),(7), and (10)
PDF Documents 2009-0859_Signature_Information_Solutions-Cumru_Twp.pdf Issued 11/25/2009 - Tax records, creation of a record
PDF Documents 2009-0874_Lemley-Perry_Twp.pdf Issued 11/25/2009 - Redacted attorney/solicitor invoices, privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0875_Lemley-Perry_Twp.pdf Issued 11/25/2009 - Receipts/invoices used for an audit, access to records
PDF Documents 2009-0919_Notorangelo-PennDOT.pdf Issued 11/25/2009 - General Policy regarding roadways and bridges, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0917_Campbell-OOR.pdf Issued 11/23/2009 - Dismissed as moot, records provided
PDF Documents 2009-0918_Maniloff-L&I.pdf Issued 11/23/2009 - Complex data set fees
PDF Documents 2009-0822_Bowders-York_Twp.pdf Issued 11/20/2009 - Sufficiently specific request, Section 703
PDF Documents 2009-0898_Marcavage-Lansdowne_Borough.pdf Issued 11/20/2009 - List of properties declared unlawful, publicly-posted notices of violation, 708(b)(16) or (b)(17).
PDF Documents 2009-0902_Hodges-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 11/20/2009 - Doctor's license, record does not exit
PDF Documents 2009-0909_Pfeiffer-Slatington_Borough.pdf Issued 11/20/2009 - Solicitor email, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0912_Williams-Lycoming_Cty.pdf Issued 11/19/2009 - Record does not exist in agency's possession, custody or control
PDF Documents 2009-0817_Shott-Banks_Twp_Municipal_Auth.pdf Issued 11/18/2009 - records do not exist – or not in possession, custody, control of agency
PDF Documents 2009-0899_Geffen-Dept_of_Agriculture.pdf Issued 11/18/2009 - Photos, dog warden reports, 708(b)(16) criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0890_Shaefer-L&I.pdf Issued 11/16/2009 - Complaint, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0895_Jones-DOC.pdf Issued 11/16/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0893_Rupp-Armstrong_SD.pdf Issued 11/16/2009 - Statement of Sch Board Director read at public meeting, non-possession
PDF Documents 2009-0894_Rhines-PSP.pdf Issued 11/16/2009 - Records do not exist in the custody, control, or possession of agency
PDF Documents 2009-0889_Buskey-OA.pdf Issued 11/13/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0879_Linthicum-York_Twp.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Communications, specifity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0881_Mincy-Lycoming_Cty.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Probation/parole records, court records, not within Agency possession.
PDF Documents 2009-0882_Moscatiello-Brentwood_Borough.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Third-party invoices to residents for refuse collection fees, 506(d), governmental function
PDF Documents 2009-0887_Chen-Tredyffin_Easttown_SD.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Request for statistics, not required to create/compile record under Sec. 705
PDF Documents 2009-0888_Addlespurger-PennDOT.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Dismissed, did not meet appeals procedure requirements
PDF Documents 2009-0820_Schillinger-PTC.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Time response logs for crashes and incidents, specificity, redaction possible
PDF Documents 2009-0839_Pavlik-PSP.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Correspondence, dismissed as moot, records received, questions not request
PDF Documents 2009-0883_Demaree-Susquehanna_Cty_COG.pdf Issued 11/12/2009 - Questions are not a proper request, COG is a local agency
PDF Documents 2009-0860_Dickey-North_Pocono_SD.pdf Issued 11/10/2009 - List of accomplishments used in review process, 708(b)(7)
PDF Documents 2009-0878_Frame-Menallen_Twp.pdf Issued 11/10/2009 - Where a requester does not request copies, it is reasonable for an agency to ask that an appointment be made to review the subject records. sufficiently specific request.
PDF Documents 2009-0885_Hosie-Bradford_Cty.pdf Issued 11/10/2009 - Noncriminal investigation 708(b)17
PDF Documents 2009-0880_White-PBPP.pdf Issued 11/10/2009 - Parole records, 37 Pa. Code §61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0871_Capinski-Upper_Pottsgrove_Twp.pdf Issued 11/09/2009 - Emails, attorney/client privilege, redaction possible
PDF Documents 2009-0780_Capinski-Upper_Pottsgrove_Twp.pdf Issued 11/09/2009 - Emails, attorney/client privilege, redaction possible
PDF Documents 2009-0869_Dowd-Department_of_State.pdf Issued 11/09/2009 - Oaths of office, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0872_Nicastro-Lehigh_Twp.pdf Issued 11/09/2009 - Dismissed as moot, records provided during course of appeal
PDF Documents 2009-0576_Oyugi-Police_Advisory_Commission.pdf Issued 11/06/2009 - Aggregated data, statistics, non-criminal investigative records
PDF Documents 2009-0836_Warner-Philadelphia_Parking_Authority.pdf Issued 11/06/2009 - Payroll records of private contractor, 506(d), governmental function
PDF Documents 2009-0866_Bowders-York_Twp.pdf Issued 11/06/2009 - Emails, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0838_Alexander-SOAB.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Investigation and assessment performed by Sexual Offender Assessment Board, 708(b)(16)(ii)
PDF Documents 2009-0854_Campbell-Central_Dauphin_SD.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Teacher's home address, Court order
PDF Documents 2009-0858_Mussari-Jermyn_Borough.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Drainage system installation records, records provided, no other records exist
PDF Documents 2009-0835_Watkins-Lehman_Twp.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Request for records of pay, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0837_Little-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Sufficiently specific request; correspondence in licensure investigation/prosecution file, 708b(17)
PDF Documents 2009-0840_Green-PBPP.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Order to recommit, 37 Pa. Code § 61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0865_Schumacher-City_of_Scranton.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0867_Ford-Delaware_Cty_Tax_Claim.pdf Issued 11/04/2009 - Rules of Bureau, enacted by Bureau; regulations or other laws governing agency, records "of" agency
more...
Final Determinations October  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0827_Miller-Newport_Twp.pdf Issued 10/30/2009 - Request specific, complaint, 708(b)(17); those records not shown to be complaints must be provided in redacted form
PDF Documents 2009-0762_Senseman-City_of_York.pdf Issued 10/30/2009 - 506(d), is a nonprofit an agency
PDF Documents 2009-0768_Gallagher-Franklin_Twp.pdf Issued 10/30/2009 - Zoning records related to an individual, emails, noncriminal investigation: other records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0801_Kyle-DCED.pdf Issued 10/29/2009 - Scoring sheets, internal memos. Pre-decisional deliberative
PDF Documents 2009-0825_Bieber-PennDOT.pdf Issued 10/29/2009 - Correspondence with insurer, 708(b)(27); police report in Agency possession, noncriminal investigative, 708 (b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-0823_Cassidy-Avon_Grove_SD.pdf Issued 10/29/2009 - Names, certified payrolls, 708(b)(6) or Pa Constitution
PDF Documents 2009-0819_Bentley-Lincoln_Borough.pdf Issued 10/28/2009 - Ordinance, fee challenge
PDF Documents 2009-0821_Schillinger-PTC.pdf Issued 10/28/2009 - 911 records, 708(b) (18) (i)
PDF Documents 2009-0815_Picollela-Lycoming_Cty.pdf Issued 10/26/2009 - Legal invoices, redaction of confidential client communications and/or mental impressions
PDF Documents 2009-0816_Toles-Juniata_Cty.pdf Issued 10/26/2009 - Records sought with certain information, not merely a list, Sec 705, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0812_Wood-Delta_Cardiff_Volunteer_Fire_Co.pdf Issued 10/26/2009 - Volunteer Fire Company subject to the RTKL, directed to provide public records.
PDF Documents 2009-0814_Turano-Greenfield_Twp.pdf Issued 10/26/2009 - Agency failed to provide competent evidence that all responsive records were provided
PDF Documents 2009-0810_Fulmer-Philadelphia_SD.pdf Issued 10/23/2009 - Complaints, settlements and attorney timesheets. redaction of students' names
PDF Documents 2009-0826_Sevick-Bucks_Cty.pdf Issued 10/23/2009 - Controller's report, 708(b)(17)
PDF Documents 2009-0806_Rhines-PSP.pdf Issued 10/21/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0807_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf Issued 10/20/2009 - Redaction of description of services from attorney invoices, attorney-client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0105_Shine-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 10/20/2009 - Email addresses, forwards of emails, license applicant, personal security 708(b)1
PDF Documents 2009-0083_Shine-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 10/20/2009 - Email addresses, forwards of emails, license applicant, personal security 708(b)1
PDF Documents 2009-0742_Kunz-DEP.pdf Issued 10/20/2009 - Emails, drafts, attorney-client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0798_Dougher-Scranton_SD.pdf Issued 10/19/2009 - Disruptive requester
PDF Documents 2009-0799_Signature_Information_Solutions-Bensalem_Twp.pdf Issued 10/19/2009 - Tax records, meeting burden
PDF Documents 2009-0797_Day-East_Stroudsburg_Area_SD.pdf Issued 10/19/2009 - Records do not exist, letter of reprimand resulting from investigation of meeting conduct, 708(b)(17) noncriminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0800_Skrocki-PSP.pdf Issued 10/19/2009 - Format of request, sufficiently specific
PDF Documents 2009-0761_Zaremba-East_Union_Twp.pdf Issued 10/16/2009 - Letters regarding findings related to audit, affadavit that all records provided
PDF Documents 2009-0715_Green-Governor_Mifflin_SD.pdf Issued 10/16/2009 - Third party contractors, certified payroll, home addresses
PDF Documents 2009-0792_Repetski-North_Lebanon_Twp.pdf Issued 10/15/2009 - Non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0794_Lambright-DOC.pdf Issued 10/15/2009 - Not a request for records, complaint
PDF Documents 2009-0748_DeSafey-South_Fayatte_PD.pdf Issued 10/14/2009 - Checkpoint police officer's names, personal security
PDF Documents 2009-0772_Bennett-Midpenn_Legal_Services.pdf Issued 10/14/2009 - Law firm receiving public funding is not a Commonwealth or local agency
PDF Documents 2009-0791_Meacher-Hanover_Borough_Police_Dept.pdf Issued 10/14/2009 - Standard Operating Procedures for bicycle and pedestrian accident investigations
PDF Documents 2009-0786_Jameson-Pittsburgh_SD.pdf Issued 10/13/2009 - Records/correspondence in possession of board members, complaints
PDF Documents 2009-0787_Shields-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf (2) Issued 10/13/2009 - Past daily schedules of Mayor and Council members, 708(b)(10), predecisional deliberations, work papers 708(b)(12), 708(b)1)(ii) personal security, public safety 708(b)(2)
PDF Documents 2009-0789_Morganti-Middletown_Twp.pdf Issued 10/13/2009 - Affidavit by agency that records were provided subsequent to appeal
PDF Documents 2009-0730_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - Attorney invoices, attorney-client privilege, work product
PDF Documents 2009-0624_Boice-Lehman_Twp.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - Past police work schedules, personal safety/public safety
PDF Documents 2009-0660_Boice-Jenkins_Twp.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - Past police work schedules, public safety
PDF Documents 2009-0720_Benevey-Blue_Mountain_Inspection_Serv.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - Privately owned company, subject to RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0766_Campbell-Pocono_Mtn_SD.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - PAC contributions and contributors, personal financial information, freedom of association
PDF Documents 2009-0785_Stoughton-Upper_Dublin_Twp.pdf Issued 10/09/2009 - Solicitor opinion letter, attorney-client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0763_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf Issued 10/07/2009 - Email correspondence, attorney-client privilege, work product
PDF Documents 2009-0657_Palatella-Erie_Western_PA_Port_Auth.pdf Issued 10/05/2009 - Real estate negotiation records prior to finalizing sale, trade secrets; not "confidential,” not “appraisals”
PDF Documents 2009-0547_Campbell-PSEA.pdf Issued 10/02/2009 - PSEA not an agency, not subject to RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0769_Miller-Uniontown_SD.pdf Issued 10/01/2009 - Interview ratings, 67.708(b)(7)
Final Determinations September  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0754_Tender-Hanover_Sewer_Authority.pdf Issued 09/30/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0771_Brown-PBPP.pdf Issued 09/29/2009 - Report to hearing examiner regarding parolee, 37 Pa. Code § 61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0765_Knauss-Unionville_Chadds_Ford_SD.pdf Issued 09/28/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0767_Rothrock-York_Cty.pdf Issued 09/28/2009 - Inmate's housing, medical, and mental health records, disciplinary and grievance records, noncriminal investigative, specificity
PDF Documents 2009-0618_Anderson-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf Issued 09/25/2009 - Sufficiently specific as it identifies a precise subject matter and seeks records related to consideration and implementation of the requirements therein
PDF Documents 2009-0707_Mumma-Juniata_Twp.pdf Issued 09/24/2009 - Attorney correspondence, attorney work product, attorney-client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0753_Reiter-Dunmore_Borough.pdf Issued 09/24/2009 - Email that concerns agency business is public record, even when received or sent from a personal computer
PDF Documents 2009-0755_Wanner-Richmond_Twp.pdf Issued 09/24/2009 - Pre-payment, fees charged
PDF Documents 2009-0747_Grumet-Department_of_Insurance.pdf Issued 09/23/2009 - Notes, considerations and analysis for rate-increase decisions, 708(b)(10), predecisional deliberative
PDF Documents 2009-0750_Callaway-Lehigh_Cty_General_Purpose_Auth.pdf Issued 09/23/2009 - Agency accepts a right-to-know request and invokes a 30-day extension, it has "received" the request pursuant to the RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0685_Lazur-Eastern_Schuylkill_Planning.pdf Issued 09/22/2009 - Intergovernmental planning commission formed pursuant to the MPC, qualifies as a "local agency
PDF Documents 2009-0646_Kantrowitz-Great_Valley_SD.pdf Issued 09/21/2009 - Emails, insufficiently specific
PDF Documents 2009-0745_Balingit-City_of_McKeesport.pdf Issued 09/21/2009 - Deemed denial, agency failed to overcome presumption of public records
PDF Documents 2009-0695_Aritz-Wyoming_Area_ SD.pdf Issued 09/18/2009 - Agency letter to Atty General, audit work papaer
PDF Documents 2009-0729_Avril-DOH.pdf Issued 09/18/2009 - Infrastructure failure and Serious event reports, MCARE Act
PDF Documents 2009-0749_Avril-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf Issued 09/18/2009 - Mental health record, incident reports
PDF Documents 2009-0734_Campbell-Office_of_the_Governor.pdf Issued 09/18/2009 - Home town information, Commonwealth Court order enjoining OOR from directing release
PDF Documents 2009-0655_Tighe-General_McLane_SD.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - Bank account number, trade secret/confidential proprietary information of redactions from Wind assessment report
PDF Documents 2009-0693_Bresliin-Dickinson_Twp.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - Record re: loss of township funds. non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0712_Gouldy-New_Cumberland_Borough.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - Draft ordinance
PDF Documents 2009-0719_Rauhauser-York_Cty.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - 911 call
PDF Documents 2009-0725_McCloskey-PTC.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - Dismissed as moot as access was provided
PDF Documents 2009-0727_Lewis-DOC.pdf Issued 09/16/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0724_Mason-PBPP.pdf Issued 09/15/2009 - Parole board records, 37 Pa. Code § 61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0723_Garrett-York_Cty.pdf Issued 09/15/2009 - List of tax properties, doesn’t exist, agency not required to create a record
PDF Documents 2009-0619_Williams-City_of_Johnstown_Civil_Serv_ Board.pdf Issued 09/14/2009 - Minutes and annual reports of Civil Service Bd to City
PDF Documents 2009-0716_Burchianti-Fayette_Cty_Conservation_Dist.pdf Issued 09/14/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0708_Housley-DOC.pdf Issued 09/14/2009 - Petition related to placing an inmate on restricted release list, 708(b)(16)
PDF Documents 2009-0673_Mezzacappa_West_Easton_Borough.pdf Issued 09/11/2009 - Complaints, Draft Orders, Written Notes, and Solicitor's Emails
PDF Documents 2009-0631_Dahlgren-DGS.pdf Issued 09/10/2009 - Trade Secret Proprietary info
PDF Documents 2009-0688_Hofherr_Lehigh_Career_&_Technical_Inst..pdf Issued 09/09/2009 - Fees for opening electronic files
PDF Documents 2009-0696_Creese-Rochester_Boro.pdf Issued 09/09/2009 - Agency did not produce documents within the time frame required by 67.902, deemed denied.
PDF Documents 2009-0608_Baker-PEBTF.pdf Issued 09/08/2009 - PEBTF not an Agency under RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0692_Baker-PennDOT.pdf Issued 09/08/2009 - Real estate appraisal and information
PDF Documents 2009-0683_Slivinski-DEP.pdf Issued 09/08/2009 - Complaint
PDF Documents 2009-0690_Harris-DOC.pdf Issued 09/08/2009 - Request for answers and explanations, not for records, section 67.701
PDF Documents 2009-0684_Fennick-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf Issued 09/04/2009 - Court order staying release, sections 67.102 and 67.305
PDF Documents 2009-0686_Walls-PSP.pdf Issued 09/04/2009 - Assignment record, 911 records
PDF Documents 2009-0540_Campbell-MCCC.pdf Issued 09/04/2009 - W-2, United Way contribution, personal financial information
PDF Documents 2009-0644_Berrett-East_Stroudsburg_Univ.pdf Issued 09/03/2009 - Forensic audit records, governmental function
PDF Documents 2009-0678_Shaner-Dept_of_Agriculture.pdf Issued 09/03/2009 - Not a proper request
PDF Documents 2009-0679_Lacoff-Owen_J_Roberts_SD.pdf Issued 09/03/2009 - Agency did not withhold public records
PDF Documents 2009-0674_Glance-Fairview_Twp.pdf Issued 09/02/2009 - Legal research/interpretation regarding Township laws/regulations
PDF Documents 2009-0675_Avery- L&I.pdf Issued 09/02/2009 - Transcripts and workers compensation payments record, 708(b)28 social services and 708(b)5 health records
PDF Documents 2009-0667_Melada-PSP.pdf Issued 09/02/2009 - Mental health records, 708(b)(5)
PDF Documents 2009-0671_Central_Blood_Bank-L&I.pdf Issued 09/02/2009 - Unemployment comp transcript/recording and exhibits, 708(b)(28)
PDF Documents 2009-0677_Hill-DOC.pdf Issued 09/02/2009 - statement, noncriminal investigation
Final Determinations August  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0663_Johnson-DOC.pdf Issued 08/31/2009 - Policy manuals, safety and investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0661_Grocki-PSP.pdf Issued 08/28/2009 - Homicide report, criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0227_McGill_&_Clark-State_College_PD.pdf Issued 08/27/2009 - Policies outlining strategies and tactics for use in major disturbances, prison riots, bomb threats, 708(b)(1)
PDF Documents 2009-0595_Wheeler-Chester_Cty_Economic_Dev_Council.pdf Issued 08/27/2009 - Not an agency under RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0651_Miller-Gettysburg_Fire_Dept.pdf Issued 08/26/2009 - Handwriting analysis and report, non-criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0652_Wei-DOH.pdf Issued 08/26/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0653_Tauro-DPW.pdf Issued 08/26/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0648_Jackson-Defender_Assn_of_Philadelphia.pdf Issued 08/26/2009 - Not an Agency under RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0638_Leslie-Borough_of_Jim_Thorpe.pdf Issued 08/24/2009 - Time card, employment records, non-criminal investigation, agency meeting burden
PDF Documents 2009-0632_Swartzwelder-Butler_Cty.pdf Issued 08/21/2009 - Personal security
PDF Documents 2009-0626_Warefield-Inspector_General.pdf Issued 08/19/2009 - Non criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0572_Gaskins-Philadelphia_Prison_System.pdf Issued 08/19/2009 - Record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0627_Durkee-Cranberry_Twp.pdf Issued 08/18/2009 - Accident report, personal identifaction information
PDF Documents 2009-0666_Viney-DOC.pdf Issued 08/18/2009 - Correctional officers' first names
PDF Documents 2009-0612_Horton-DOC.pdf Issued 08/17/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0556_Mychak-Mt_Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 08/14/2009 - Insurance policies and payments, individually identifiable health info and confidential identifiers, 708(b)(6) and (b)(5)
PDF Documents 2009-0605_Ostrander-Hatboro_Borough.pdf Issued 08/14/2009 - Electric study, Agency provided no support for not providing
PDF Documents 2009-0596_Rankin-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf Issued 08/13/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0431_Campbell-Schuylkill_Cty.pdf Issued 08/13/2009 - Electronic format of agreements
PDF Documents 2009-0144_Signature_Info_Solutions-PGW.pdf Issued 08/13/2009 - Software installation for ease of obtaining records
PDF Documents 2009-0522_McGarvey-PSP.pdf Issued 08/13/2009 - Homicide investigation, criminal investigative, CHRIA
PDF Documents 2009-0593_Rohland-DOC.pdf Issued 08/12/2009 - Records not in possession
PDF Documents 2009-0628_Shuler-DOC.pdf Issued 08/12/2009 - Nutrition handbook, record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0656_Davila-DOC.pdf Issued 08/12/2009 - Medical incident report, 708(b)5
PDF Documents 2009-0570_Mychak-Mt._Carmel_Twp.pdf Issued 08/12/2009 - Audit report
PDF Documents 2009-0621_Dickerson-DOC.pdf Issued 08/12/2009 - Book sections referred to in footnotes, copyright protection
PDF Documents 2009-0508_Lewis-PSP.pdf Issued 08/11/2009 - Incident report, noncriminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0591_Alexander-SOAB.pdf Issued 08/10/2009 - Request insufficiently specific
PDF Documents 2009-0590_Stricker-DEP.pdf Issued 08/10/2009 - Unredacted copy of complaint, noncriminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0592_Shott-Banks Twp.pdf Issued 08/10/2009 - Requested items provided, verbal amendment of request
PDF Documents 2009-0609_Dougherty-DOE.pdf Issued 08/07/2009 - Communications, investigative, 608(b)17
PDF Documents 2009-0659_Eckstein-Butler Cty. Bd._of_Commissioners.pdf Issued 08/07/09 - Copying fee for records
PDF Documents 2009-0551_Werner-Pittsburgh_SD.pdf Issued 08/07/2009 - Pre-decisional deliberations
PDF Documents 2009-0614_Perez-DOC.pdf Issued 08/06/2009 - Record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0588_Barnes-DOC.pdf Issued 08/05/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0581_Flick-Borough_ of_ Baldwin.pdf Issued 08/05/2009 - Fee charges
PDF Documents 2009-0489_Moll-Borough_of_Hatboro.pdf Issued 08/04/2009 - Redaction of non-public information
PDF Documents 2009-0578_Tignall-Dallastown SD.pdf Issued 08/04/2009 - Record of bank investigator not record of School District
PDF Documents 2009-0586_Gaskins-DOC.pdf Issued 08/04/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0531_Sliwinski-Newtown_Twp.pdf Issued 08/03/2009 - Records did not exist in requested format
PDF Documents 2009-0565_Fleck-Department_of_Revenue.pdf Issued 08/03/2009 - Confidentiality provisions on tax return
PDF Documents 2009-0567_Simatic-PennDOT.pdf Issued 08/03/2009 - Construction plans, Right of way access
PDF Documents 2009-0575_ DePhillippo-Worcester Twp.pdf Issued 08/03/2009 - Complaints, non-investigative
Final Determinations July  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0563_Jackson-Philadelphia_PD.pdf Issued 07/31/2009 - Visitors log, records do not exist, no affadavit
PDF Documents 2009-0494_Day-East_Stroudsburg_SD.pdf Issued 07/30/2009 - Attorney fees and invoices
PDF Documents 2009-0561_Schumaker-City_of_Scranton.pdf Issued 07/30/2009 - No further records exist
PDF Documents 2009-0562_Shea-PSP.pdf Issued 07/30/2009 - State Police - Act 180 recertification exams, 708(b)(7)(iii)
PDF Documents 2009-0239_Stamus-Tunkhannock_Twp_Fire_Comp.pdf Issued 07/30/2009 - No further records exist
PDF Documents 2009-0453_Dreyer-DEP.pdf Issued 07/29/2009 - Noncriminal investigative, lack of specificity, repeat request, record does not exist or already provided
PDF Documents 2009-0532_Sheldon-PSP.pdf Issued 07/29/2009 - Record fees for Media
PDF Documents 2009-0583_Howard-DOC.pdf Issued 07/29/2009 - Record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0479_Weber-SEPTA.pdf Issued 07/29/2009 - Record does not exist, in process
PDF Documents 2009-0564_Stevens-Adams_Cty_Solicitor.pdf Issued 07/2/2009 - GFOA, predeliberative
PDF Documents 2009-0459_Howard-DOC.pdf Issued 07/28/2009 - Draft policy, 708(b) )(1O)(i)(A)
PDF Documents 2009-0488_Commonwealth_Education_Org-DOE.pdf Issued 07/27/2009 - Electronic access, email of information, creation of a record
PDF Documents 2009-0541_McShane-Perry_Cty.pdf Issued 07/27/2009 - 911 transcripts, car communications
PDF Documents 2009-0545_Baldwin-PUC.pdf Issued 07/27/2009 - Incident report, exempt under another statute
PDF Documents 2009-0249_Kline-PennDOT.pdf (2) Issued 07/24/2009 - Vehicle inspection report, agency not in possession
PDF Documents 2009-0478_Nelle-PennDelco_ SD.pdf Issued 07/24/2009 - Emails
PDF Documents 2009-0553_Campanelli-City_of_Erie.pdf Issued 07/24/2009 - Notice of Violation, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0477_Nelle-PennDelco_SD.pdf Issued 07/23/2009 - Non-criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0534_Ziccardi-PSP.pdf Issued 07/23/2009 - IAD investigavtive report, non-criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0527_Meehan-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf Issued 07/22/2009 - Non-responsive agency
PDF Documents 2009-0538_Lerner-City_of_Philadelphia_Parking_Auth.pdf Issued 07/21/2009 - Agency not in possession of records
PDF Documents 2009-0450_Dreyer-DEP.pdf Issued 07/20/2009 - Non-criminal investigative, repeat requests, specificity
PDF Documents 2009-0509_Walker-Macungie_PD.pdf Issued 07/20/2009 - Police work schedules, 708(b)2
PDF Documents 2009-0512_Rotenberg-Montgomery_Cty_Revelopment_Auth.pdf Issued 07/20/2009 - Predecisional, proprietary information
PDF Documents 2009-0525_Grossman-Wyomissing_PD.pdf Issued 07/20/2009 - Agency did not provide legal basis for denial, did not bear burden
PDF Documents 2009-0498_Maller-West_Manheim_Twp.pdf Issued 07/17/2009 - Construction plans, trade secrets
PDF Documents 2009-0506_Kissell-Portage_Twp.pdf Issued 07/17/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0495_Vonderheide-Lancaster_Cty_DA.pdf Issued 07/16/2009 - 911 audio tapes
PDF Documents 2009-0487_Goodman-Securities_Commission.pdf Issued 07/15/2009 - Agreement and Undertakings showing payment of settlement amount, investigative, agency regulation
PDF Documents 2009-0493_Ungvarsky-Scranton.pdf Issued 07/15/2009 - Agency provided records, others are held by other Agency
PDF Documents 2009-0243_Smith_and_Miller-Gaming_Control_Board.pdf Issued 07/14/2009 - Fees, creation of a record
PDF Documents 2009-0492_Cunningham-Upper_Uwchlan_Twp.pdf Issued 07/13/2009 - Records of final action on discharge supplied, agency not required to answer questions
PDF Documents 2009-0516_Hicks-DOC.pdf Issued 07/10/2009 - Mental health records, 708(b)5
PDF Documents 2009-0496_Cooley-PBPP.pdf issued 07/10/2009 - Judge's letter re: prisoner parole release, 37 Pa. Code § 61.2
PDF Documents 2009-0460_Mollick-Worcester_Twp.pdf Issued 07/08/2009 - Twp Supervisor emails, Twp control, records prior to 2009
PDF Documents 2009-0481_Zachariah-DOC.pdf Issued 07/08/2009 - Prison video surveillance footage
PDF Documents 2009-0482_Kiesling-PennDOT.pdf Issued 07/07/2009 - Records requested in specific format
PDF Documents 2009-0473_Gold-Bucks_Cty_Municipal_Auth.pdf Issued 07/06/2009 - Legal invoices, litigation strategy, attorney/client privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0430_Campbell-Cambria_County.pdf Issued 07/06/2009 - Home addresses, county email addresses
PDF Documents 2009-0471_Brown-DOC.pdf Issued 07/06/2009 - Fee charge, access
PDF Documents 2009-0429_Borriello-Baden_Boro.pdf Issued 07/02/2009 - Minutes, historical records
PDF Documents 2009-0432_Campbell-Central_York_SD.pdf Issued 07/02/2009 - Minutes, W-2's
PDF Documents 2009-0465_Weiss-PSP.pdf Issued 07/02/2009 - Incident reports/blotter information, CHRIA, 708(b)16
PDF Documents 2009-0539_Zacher-PSP.pdf Issued 07/24/2009 - Fire reports, photographs, non-criminal investigation
Final Determinations June  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0452_Veltri-New_Kensington_City.pdf Issued 06/29/2009 - Investigative report, noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0428_Burton-Scranton_Parking_Auth.pdf Issued 06/25/2009 - Leases, personal financial information
PDF Documents 2009-0433_Campbel- Wayne_Cty.pdf Issued 06/25/2009 - County issued email addresses
PDF Documents 2009-0418_Lopez-PSP.pdf Issued 06/19/2009 - Assignment report, noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0417_Houck-Muhlenberg_Twp.pdf Issued 06/18/2009 - Complaint, noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0303_Austin-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 06/18/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0407_Bruce-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 06/15/2009 - Noncriminal investigative, complaint
PDF Documents 2009-0376_Allen-PennDOT.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - Difficult retrieval
PDF Documents 2009-0377_Thompson-DOC.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - Academic transcript, DC-47c transcript
PDF Documents 2009-0378_Aschman-DOH.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - Investigative, complaint
PDF Documents 2009-0381_Amos-Dept_of_Banking.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - MOU's, Dept of Banking Code
PDF Documents 2009-0321_Schmitz-PTC.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - RFP's, contract award, pre-decisional, traade secret
PDF Documents 2009-0273_Jelsma-McNett_Twp.pdf Issued 06/05/2009 - No issue to public nature, township did not respond timely
PDF Documents 2009-0367_Gusler-Jefferson_Twp.pdf Issued 06/05/2009 - Emails with solicitor, receipts, tax collector reports, ordinances
PDF Documents 2009-0373_Campbell-Centre_Cty.pdf Issued 06/05/2009 - County employee email addresses, computer security
PDF Documents 2009-0365_Benevy-Lansford_Borough.pdf Issued 06/04/2009 - Building inspection reports, HVAC and fire alarm specs, non-criminal investigative, personal security
PDF Documents 2009-0382_Setaro-PennDOT.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - Vehicle records
PDF Documents 2009-0383_Foster-PBPP.pdf Issued 06/10/2009 - Creation of a record, agency not in possession
PDF Documents 2009-0393_Brossman-East_Hempfield_Twp.pdf Issued 06/23/2009 - Records provided, moot
PDF Documents 2009-0395_McKee-DOC.pdf Issued 06/09/2009 - DC-47a, academic transcript
PDF Documents 2009-0399_Caldwell-DOC.pdf Issued 06/12/2009 - Medical records
PDF Documents 2009-0404_Siegel-PSP.pdf Issued 06/12/2009 - Accident reporst, request to wrong agency
PDF Documents 2009-0413_Hess-DOC.pdf Issued 06/16/2009 - Prepayment of fess
PDF Documents 2009-0422_Kirkpatrick-DPW.pdf Issued 06/19/2009 - Employment applications
PDF Documents 2009-0235_Ober-Plumstead_Twp.pdf Issued 06/26/2009 - Records provided previously, no other responsive records
PDF Documents 2009-0259_Kline-PennDOT.pdf Issued 06/24/2009 - Driver registration numbers
PDF Documents 2009-0348_Turney-PennDOT.pdf Issued 06/15/2009 - Consultant report, predecisional deliberations
PDF Documents 2009-0350_Campbell-Colonial_SD.pdf Issued 06/12/2009 - W-2 information, Box 12
PDF Documents 2009-0351_Campbell-Montgomery_County_IU.pdf Issued 06/12/2009 - W-2 information, Box 12
PDF Documents 2009-0426_Richter-Lower_Paxton_Twp.pdf Issued 06/22/2009 - Complaint, non-criminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0435_Signature_Info_Solutions-Springfield_SD.pdf Issued 06/19/2009 - tax records, creation of record, agency records in possession of third party (tax collector)
PDF Documents 2009-0437_Martucci-DOS.pdf Issued 06/25/2009 - Investigation file, noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0441_Barget-South_Eastern_SD.pdf Issued 06/22/2009 - Proposed budget
PDF Documents 2009-0444_Keisling-Lancaster_County_DA.pdf Issued 06/29/2009 - Coroner's report
PDF Documents 2009-0447_Meachem-East_Stroudsburg_SD.pdf Issued 06/29/2009 - All records in existence found to have been provided
PDF Documents 2009-0448_Meachem-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf Issued 06/29/2009 - Solicitor's invoices, redaction
PDF Documents 2009-0449_Martin-DOC.pdf Issued 06/29/2009 - Housing report and vote sheets, personal security, public safety/law enforcement
PDF Documents 2009-0462_Shaffer-DOC.pdf Issued 06/30/2009 - Noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0467_Reveley-Dauphin_Cty.pdf Issued 06/30/2009 - Copy fees, waiving fees
PDF Documents 2009-0353_Wykoff-PSP.pdf Issued 06/01/2009 - Police assignment report, non-criminal investigative
PDF Documents 2009-0354_Marwah-Franklin_Park_Borough.pdf Issued 06/01/2009 - Records not in Agency's possession
PDF Documents 2009-0356_KatzManheim_Central_SD.pdf 2007 Standard Schedule.xls
PDF Documents 2009-0358_Rohland-DOC.pdf Issued 06/03/2009 - Photographs, Agency not in possession
PDF Documents 2009-0359_Marino-Kutztown_Borough.pdf Issued 06/03/2009 - All records provided, others do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0366_D'Alfonso-Securities_Commission.pdf Issued 06/05/2009 - Specificity, compilation/format, court order
PDF Documents 2009-0372_Campbell-Susquehanna_Cty.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 - Law enforcement officer addresses, children and youth caseworker addresses, personal security
PDF Documents 2009-0379_Turney-PennDOT.pdf Issued 06/08/2009 -
PDF Documents 2009-0387_Ali-PAID.pdf Issued 06/10/2009 - Records provided, others do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0391_Wei-DOH.pdf Issued 06/10/2009 - Specificity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0392_Signature_Info_Systems-Peters_Creek_Sewer_Auth.pdf Issued 06/11/2009 - Requiring signature, fees
more...
Final Determinations May  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0286_Piwonski_&_Meyers-DRJTB_Commission.pdf Issued 05/29/2009 - Records provided, more specific do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0282_Dean-Lycoming_County.pdf Issued 05/29/2009 - GIS fees
PDF Documents 2009-0340 Cambell-Interboro_SD.pdf Issued 05/28/2009 - W-2 information, fees charged
PDF Documents 2009-0238_George-Rome_Township.pdf Issued 05/27/2009 - Auditor correspondence, predecisional
PDF Documents 2009-0334_Maxwell-Shippensburg_PD.pdf Issued 05/27/2009 - Extensive search required for records, agency providing on ongoing basis
PDF Documents 2009-0333_Cohen-L&I.pdf Issued 05/27/2009 - Non-criminal investigative, disruptive requester
PDF Documents 2009-0335_Martin-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 05/27/2009 - Agency not in possession of records
PDF Documents 2009-0326_Shea-City_of_Coatesville.pdf Issued 05/26/2009 - Dates of birth, hometown, public employees
PDF Documents 2009-0328_Stewart-Lehigh_Township.pdf Issued 05/26/2009 - Agency provided records
PDF Documents 2009-0329_Stewart-Lehigh_Township.pdf Issued 05/26/2009 - Agency provided records
PDF Documents 2009-0339_Czech-York_County.pdf Issued 05/26/2009 - Issue decided in previous appeal
PDF Documents 2009-0307_Rusch-DOC.pdf Issued 05/22/2009 - Prison procedure/policy manual
PDF Documents 2009-0323_Gebhart-Bonneauville_Community_Fire_Co.pdf Issued 05/22/2009 - Fire Companies are Agencies under RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0228_Williams-Lehigh_County.pdf Issued 05/21/2009 - Agency provided all records
PDF Documents 2009-0226_Harasti-DGS.pdf Issued 05/20/2009 - Floor plans
PDF Documents 2009-0230_Campbell-Boyertown_Area_SD.pdf Issued 05/20/2009 - W-2, Box 14
PDF Documents 2009-0234_Hoffman-Lehigh_Township.pdf Issued 05/20/2009 - Providing access to records, requiring payment for copies
PDF Documents 2009-0260_Healy-State_Ethics_Commission.pdf Issued 05/19/2009 - Blanket denial, redaction is possible
PDF Documents 2009-0299_Signature_Info_Solutions-Nether_Providence_Twp.pdf Issued 05/18/2009 - Tax and sewer payment history
PDF Documents 2009-0314_Montgomery-Twin_Valley_SD.pdf Issued 05/18/2009 - Non-possession of records
PDF Documents 2009-0315_Schillinger-Single_Tax_Office.pdf Issued 05/18/2009 - Employment applications and resumes
PDF Documents 2009-0296_Cohens-L&I.pdf Issued 05/18/2009 - Duplicative requests
PDF Documents 2009-0302_Thompson-Dickinson_Twp.pdf Issued 05/18/2009 - Attorney/client privilege, legal support required
PDF Documents 2009-0208_Fenton-PHFA.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Addresses, GLB Act, Act 91 Notices
PDF Documents 2009-0258_Day-East_Stroudsburg_Area_SD.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Audit report, underlying work papers
PDF Documents 2009-0290_Zingaretti-DCED.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Pre-decisional, supporting grant/funding application information
PDF Documents 2009-0297_Nolen-William_Penn_SD.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Agency provided all records in possession
PDF Documents 2009-0240_Day-East_Stroudsburg_Area_SD.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Pre-decisional emails
PDF Documents 2009-0269_Campbell-Souderton_SD.pdf Issued 05/14/2009 - W-2 information
PDF Documents 2009-0285_Cohen-L&I.pdf Issued 05/14/2009 - Investigative records, supplied by party making request
PDF Documents 2009-0288_Selig-Dept_of_State.pdf Issued 05/13/2009 - Noncriminal investigation
PDF Documents 2009-0278_Boyer-North_Schuylkill_SD.pdf Issued 05/08/2009 - No records exist, discernment of records requested, agency did not embody spirit of the law
PDF Documents 2009-0194_Wilson-Newtown_Township.pdf Issued 05/08/2009 - Records do not exist, no agency attestation
PDF Documents 2009-0275_Quinn-City_of_Scranton.pdf Issued 05/08/2009 - Record does not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0277_Boyer-North_Schuylkill_SD.pdf Issued 05/08/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0272_Marino-Kutztown_Borough.pdf Issued 05/07/2009 - Purchase order is record even though not executed
PDF Documents 2009-0270_Houck-Martic_Township.pdf Issued 05/06/2009 - Solicitor letter, privilege
PDF Documents 2009-0271_Hoffman-Lehigh_Twp.pdf Issued 05/06/2009 - Garbage bill payments, personal financial information
PDF Documents 2009-0264_Rogan-Montessori_Regional_Charter_School.pdf Issued 05/06/2009 - Letter about special education student, FERPA
PDF Documents 2009-0266_Faust-DOC.pdf Issued 05/06/2009 - record not in possession of the agency
PDF Documents 2009-0154_Ali-DCED.pdf Issued 05/04/2009 - Financial reports submitted to DCED, draft operating agreement
PDF Documents 2009-0256_Smith-Quakertown_Community_SD.pdf Issued 05/04/2009 - Athletic budget, partially projected at meeting
PDF Documents 2009-0257_Leather-Morrisville_SD.pdf Issued 05/04/2009 - Records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0248_Mazazarese-Conemaugh_Twp_Municipal_Auth.pdf Issued 05/04/2009 - Infrastructure exception, complete denial when parts can be redacted
PDF Documents 2009-0140_Stamus-Carbon_County.pdf Issued 05/01/2009 - 911 tapes
PDF Documents 2009-0219_Jones-Game_Commission.pdf Issued 05/01/2009 - Prior OOR ruling binding, possession of records, records previously provided
PDF Documents 2009-0247_Meachem-Pocono_Mountain_SD.pdf Issued 05/01/2009 - Records do not exist, others provided
PDF Documents 2009-0254_Mengel-Snyder_Township.pdf Issued 05/01/2009 - Records mentioned at a public meeting, agency possession/control
PDF Documents 2009-0201_Vogt-North_Hills_SD.pdf Issued 05/15/2009 - Third party contractor, home addresses
PDF Documents 2009-0341_Dilger-Pocono_Mountain_Charter_School.pdf Issued 05/28/2009 - No response from agency, deemed denial
more...
Final Determinations April  
  Name Description
PDF Documents 2009-0241_Meachem-East_Stroudsburg_Area_SD.pdf Issued 04/30/2009 - Non-criminal investigation reports
PDF Documents 2009-0242_Weller-PBPP.pdf Issued 04/30/2009 - Civil Service results
PDF Documents 2009-0210_Murin-PennDOT.pdf Issued 04/27/2009 - Section 705 , collection of records from other sources, not created or reorganized
PDF Documents 2009-0212_Campbell-Berwick_Area_SD.pdf Issued 04/24/2009 - W-2's, union dues deduction, personal financial information
PDF Documents 2009-0232_Guyer-Department_of_Heatlth.pdf Issued 04/24/2009 - Request for complaints filed
PDF Documents 2009-0167_Kennedy-Dept_of_Revenue.pdf Issued 04/24/2009 - Non-possession; Section 704 does not permit advising of electronic access only; Sec. 701 requires access by inspection or duplication.
PDF Documents 2009-0175_Carter-Philadelphia_Sheriffs.pdf Issued 04/23/2009 - Voluminous reccords, retrieval still necessary
PDF Documents 2009-0192_McShane-PSP.pdf Issued 04/22/2009 - Specificity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0221_Donahue-Wall_St_West.pdf Issued 04/22/2009 - Non-profit organization, not subject to RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0191_McShane-PSP.pdf Issued 04/22/2009 - Specificity of request
PDF Documents 2009-0209_Ali-PAID.pdf Issued 04/20/2009 - Provide records when know what requester seeks, records do not exist
PDF Documents 2009-0188_Fischer-Newtown_Township.pdf Issued 04/17/2009 - Numerous, non-duplicative requests, not a disruptive requester
PDF Documents 2009-0204_Ferenchick-Wilkes_Barre_SD.pdf Issued 04/17/2009 - Personnel records, agency not compliant with RTKL in response
PDF Documents 2009-0100_Bolgiano-Game_Commission.pdf Issued 04/17/2009 - Request for answers to questions, not records
PDF Documents 2009-0138_Lang-City_of_Philadelphia.pdf Issued 04/17/2009 - No records exist
PDF Documents 2009-0182_Nolen-City_of_Williamsport.pdf Issued 04/14/2009 - Agency provided records, no partial denial
PDF Documents 2009-0119_Pry-IUP.pdf Issued 04/14/2009 - Home addresses of 3rd Party Contractor
PDF Documents 2009-0183_Hernandez-Bermudian_Springs_SD.pdf Issued 04/14/2009 - Records do not exist, procedures
PDF Documents 2009-0169_Schillinger-Lackawawanna_Cty.pdf Issued 04/14/2009 - Agency issued cellular telephone numbers
PDF Documents 2009-0178_Nernberg-Allegheny_Cty.pdf Issued 04/13/2009 - Social services recepient, protected by statute and RTKL
PDF Documents 2009-0070_Pry-Butler_Cty_Community_College.pdf Issued 04/13/2009 - Home addresses, 3rd party contractor
PDF Documents 2009-0151_Roe-Penndel_Borough.pdf Issued 04/13/2009 - Retrieval of records
PDF Documents